College Football Playoff Overkill?

By: Kenneth Harrison

TheSouthernSportsEdition.com news services

This is the final year of the 12-team College Football Playoffs before the 24-team format starts in 2027.

It’s exciting to have playoffs at the FBS level but there aren’t twelve teams that can actually compete for a national championship. Adding twelve additional teams means there will be more blowouts in the early rounds.

Regarding expansion, the CFP issued the following statement:
“The decision to expand was driven by a desire to increase opportunities for FBS programs, student-athletes and fan bases to participate in the Playoff and have a chance to play for the CFP National Championship, while new scheduling standards incentivize institutions to schedule more compelling non-conference matchups during the regular season. The expanded format will feature 16 on-campus Playoff games, which will bring Playoff football to more students and local fans while providing a positive impact for campus communities.”

The four primary principles for the CFP rankings are strength of schedule (SOS), head-to-head results, results against common opponents and other relevant factors (coaching changes, major injuries or roster availability).

Automatic bids are guaranteed to the champions of the ACC, Big Ten, Big 12, and SEC, plus the highest-ranked team from the American, Conference USA, MAC, Mountain West, Pac-12, or Sun Belt. Notre Dame loses its previous guaranteed automatic bid status.

The 19 at-large bids are awarded to the highest-ranked remaining teams according to the CFP Selection Committee’s final rankings

Seeds 1–8 earn a first-round bye and host a second-round campus game. Seeds 9–16 host a first-round game on campus. Seeds 17–24 travel to play first-round games at Seeds 9–16.  The Quarterfinals and Semifinals will be hosted across the six traditional CFP bowl games (Cotton, Fiesta, Orange, Peach, Rose, and Sugar).

CFP Executive Director, Rich Clark: “We will make the 24-team Playoff spectacular for the fans, student-athletes, their institutions and all our stakeholders. That is our commitment. Our organization delivers a world-class championship experience at our games and our events, and this promise will continue under the new format. 23 games of Playoff football, featuring 24 ranked teams going head-to-head for the right to be crowned the true national champion.”

Let’s take a look at the 2025 CFP rankings to see how the playoffs would have been using this format.

Indiana, Ohio State, Georgia, Texas Tech, Oregon, Ole Miss, Texas A&M, Oklahoma, Alabama, Miami, Notre Dame, BYU, Texas, Vanderbilt, Utah, USC, Arizona, Michigan, Virginia, Tulane, Houston, Georgia Tech, Iowa and James Madison.

You will notice immediately how different it would have been. Unranked Duke (7-5) won the ACC Championship so they would have been in as an automatic bid. Indiana, Georgia, Texas Tech and Tulane would round out the automatic bids.

Ohio State, Oregon and Ole Miss would be the remaining teams in the top eight to receive a first-round bye.

Duke being added would push James Madison outside of the top 24.

In the first-round the matchups would be: Texas A&M vs Iowa, Oklahoma vs Georgia Tech, Alabama vs Houston, BYU vs Houston, Miami vs Virginia, Notre Dame vs Michigan, BYU vs Arizona, Texas vs USC and Vandy vs Utah.

I’m not sure if this would have changed the final outcome of the national championship between Indiana and Miami but it would have added some additional games against major programs.

I believe this new format will make the opening round like a normal bowl game was before the BCS bowls (that’s old school).