Texas Longhorns
Not My Fault
By: Michael Spiers
TheSouthernSportsEdition.com news services
Arch Manning was supposed to be the next big thing. The next great quarterback in the Manning line, the guy who would bring Texas football back to the national stage, and the face of college football’s new generation.
I even wrote a glowing article about him for this publication just over a month ago. But here we are, five games into the 2025 season, and the story looks a lot different than anyone expected.
Texas is 3-2, the playoff dream is already slipping, and the most famous name in college football is taking more heat than ever.
The numbers tell part of the story. Manning has completed around 60 percent of his passes for 1,158 yards with 11 touchdowns and five interceptions. He’s also leading the team in rushing, which says a lot about both his toughness and the chaos around him.
He’s made some highlight plays that remind everyone why he was so hyped, but he’s also made too many risky throws. That mix of brilliance and inconsistency has defined his first real run as QB1.
The spotlight has been brutal. Every pass, every expression, every misstep gets analyzed like it’s a presidential debate.
Steve Sarkisian even joked about reporters breaking down Manning’s body language. One SEC coach summed it up perfectly: “He throws a bad pass; he’s the worst quarterback in the world. He throws a good pass, he’s gonna win the Heisman.” It’s impossible to live up to that kind of pressure.
And when you look closer, it’s easy to see why things are rough. Manning is a first-year starter in the SEC behind an offensive line that has struggled badly.
Texas has allowed pressure on over 40 percent of dropbacks, which ranks near the bottom nationally.
In the loss to Florida, he was sacked six times and hit on more than half of his throws. No quarterback thrives in those conditions.
The help around him hasn’t been great either. Texas lost its top tackle and top wide receiver to the NFL, and injuries in the backfield have killed the run game.
The wideouts who were supposed to step up haven’t delivered. So, Manning has been trying to do too much, forcing throws because he doesn’t have many safe options.
Of course, not all of the issues are on the team.
Manning’s footwork has been inconsistent, and he’s been holding the ball too long. His average time to throw is over three seconds, one of the slowest in college football. That’s a dangerous habit behind a weak line.
He’s also missed some easy completions that should be automatic in Sarkisian’s offense. These are things that come with inexperience, but they add up fast.
The coaching hasn’t exactly made life easier.
Sarkisian keeps dialing up deep passing plays that take time to develop, even though his line can’t protect and his young quarterback needs simpler reads. Manning’s average target is 12 yards downfield, which is one of the highest in the country.
The problem is, Texas barely throws short passes. They have fewer quick throws than almost any major program. Instead of building confidence with short routes and screens, they keep asking Manning to go for big plays that often blow up before they start.
What’s getting lost in all the noise is that Arch Manning is still learning, and he’s doing it under more pressure than almost anyone in college football history.
Coaches and teammates say he’s handled it all with maturity and toughness. The problem isn’t that he’s failed to live up to the hype. It’s that no one could live up to the hype that followed his name.
Even the best Mannings had growing pains. Peyton threw 11 interceptions as a freshman. Eli didn’t become a star until his third year. Arch is just going through his version of that, only every moment is broadcast to the world.
The truth is, Arch Manning isn’t broken. He’s just in a tough spot. Texas needs a lot more help up front and a smarter game plan.
He’ll get better as the season goes on, but he was never going to be a miracle worker overnight.
Arch Manning will be fine. He’s talented, tough, and learning how to lead through fire.
Maybe the real story isn’t that he fell short, but that the expectations were never fair in the first place.
Should I Stay Or Should I Go?
By: Michael Spiers
TheSouthernSportsEdition.com news services
Arch Manning has not even played his first full season as the Texas starter and the talk has already shifted to his future.
Will he be a one-year starter who takes off for the NFL in 2026, or will he do what Peyton and Eli did and stick around for four full years before making the leap?
It is not an easy question, but it is one that shows just how unique Arch’s situation is.
The NFL is obviously interested. Everywhere you look you see him ranked as the number one or number two overall prospect for 2026 and the top quarterback on the board.
People who study the game see the arm strength, the mobility, and the calm presence that stood out when he stepped in last year.
His limited stats still popped off the page. Eight touchdowns, only two picks, and more than 800 yards on just 72 passes.
In today’s game, where guys like Caleb Williams and Bryce Young left school after two years of starting, Arch could very easily go early too.
But there is a catch. Arch has barely played. He has fewer than 250 career snaps, which is the same as about three and a half games. Even if he starts every game this season, that still leaves him with only 18 career starts.
When you look at the current NFL, almost every starting quarterback had 25 or more starts in college. That experience matters when you are running the most important position on the field.
This is where family history comes in. Peyton went back to Tennessee for his senior year even though he was already projected as the first pick. Eli stayed at Ole Miss when he could have gone out early.
Both of them believed in being patient, in developing more before cashing in. Arch has shown the same kind of mindset. He stayed at Texas behind Quinn Ewers instead of transferring. That tells me he is not in a rush.
Money also does not change the equation like it used to. In the past, leaving early meant you secured your first big contract sooner. Today, staying in school can be just as profitable thanks to NIL.
Arch is already tied in with brands like Red Bull, Panini, Uber, and EA Sports. His family is more than secure financially and being the quarterback at Texas brings seven figures in NIL deals anyway.
There is also the idea of legacy. Texas is ranked number one to start the season and they believe they can win a national championship.
If they fall short, does Arch decide he wants one more crack at it in 2026? It is possible. He has talked about how much he loves Austin, his teammates, and the program. That could make it easier to stay.
NFL scouts are excited but also cautious. They know he looks the part, but they want to see how he handles the road trips against teams like Ohio State, Florida, and Georgia this year.
They want to know if he can stay calm when the spotlight is brightest. Until then, he is still more potential than proven.
The Mannings have always played the long game. Eli held out on draft day because the Chargers were not the right fit. Peyton turned down the NFL as a junior even though he was a lock to go first overall.
Arch may make his decision based more on where he might land in 2026 than when he could be drafted. If the right team has the top pick, maybe he goes. If not, sticking at Texas makes sense.
If you ask me, Arch should wait. Give it another year, get more starts, build up confidence, and maybe bring Texas a national title.
He does not need the money and he does not need to race his uncles to the NFL. What he needs is to be fully ready when he gets there.
And if history tells us anything, patience has worked out pretty well for the Manning family.
Hook Em Horns
By: Jeff Doke
TheSouthernSportsEdition.com news services
The Texas Longhorns enter the 2025 college football season with sky-high expectations, poised to contend for both the SEC Championship and a national title.
Coming off back-to-back College Football Playoff (CFP) semifinal appearances and a 13-3 record in 2024, head coach Steve Sarkisian’s fifth season at the helm has the program buzzing with anticipation.
With a talented roster, a favorable SEC schedule, and a new quarterback in Arch Manning, the Longhorns are projected as the preseason No. 1 team in the AP Poll, a testament to their reloaded roster and championship aspirations.
The biggest storyline for 2025 is the ascension of redshirt sophomore Arch Manning to QB1, succeeding Quinn Ewers, drafted this spring by the NFL’s Miami Dolphins.
Manning, a former five-star recruit with a storied football lineage, showed flashes of brilliance in 2024, completing 61 of 90 passes for 939 yards, nine touchdowns, and two interceptions across 10 games, including starts against Louisiana Monroe and Mississippi State.
His dual-threat ability—evidenced by 108 rushing yards and four scores—draws comparisons to Texas legend Vince Young.
Coach Sarkisian praises Manning’s work ethic, noting his dedication in the film room and weight room as key to his development. However, with only two starts under his belt, Manning’s ability to handle the pressure of a grueling schedule will be critical.
Behind him, the quarterback depth includes transfer Matthew Caldwell, redshirt freshman Trey Owens, and 4-star freshman KJ Lacey, providing insurance should injuries arise.
Despite losing 12 players to the 2025 NFL Draft, including four of five offensive linemen and key defensive starters, Texas has reloaded with the nation’s No. 1 recruiting class and impactful transfers.
The offensive line, a major question mark, will rely on senior center Cole Hutson to anchor a rebuilt unit. The departure of left tackle Kelvin Banks Jr., a top-10 NFL Draft pick, leaves big shoes to fill, but Sarkisian remains optimistic about the group’s potential.
At running back, Quintrevion Wisner (1,064 yards in 2024) and CJ Baxter, returning from a torn ACL, form a dynamic duo.
Sophomore wide receiver Ryan Wingo is expected to emerge as Manning’s primary target after a strong freshman campaign.
Defensively, junior linebacker Anthony Hill Jr. (113 tackles, 8.0 sacks in 2024) and senior safety Michael Taaffe (78 tackles, 10 pass breakups) anchor a unit that ranked third nationally in yards allowed (284.3 per game) last season.
Transfers like defensive tackles Travis Shaw and Cole Brevard, along with sophomore edge rusher Colin Simmons, bolster a reloaded defensive line.
Texas faces one of the toughest schedules in college football, starting with a blockbuster road game against defending national champion Ohio State on August 30.
A rematch of the 2024 CFP semifinal, where Texas fell 28-14, this game will test Manning’s readiness against an elite Buckeye defense.
Other key matchups include a trip to Georgia on October 18, a revenge game after two losses to the Bulldogs in 2024, and the renewed Lone Star Showdown against Texas A&M on November 28.
The Red River Rivalry against Oklahoma in Dallas on October 11 adds further intensity. However, Texas avoids Alabama, LSU, and Ole Miss, giving them a favorable SEC slate.
Vegas has them at a 9.5 win total, with likely wins against San Jose State, UTEP, Sam Houston, Mississippi State, and Vanderbilt, and 50/50 games against Florida, Kentucky, and Arkansas. Splitting the Ohio State and Georgia games could position Texas for an 11-1 record and a return to the CFP.
To reach their national title goal, Texas must address 2024’s shortcomings: nine penalties and two turnovers against Ohio State, red zone struggles (scoring under 80%), and too many tackles for loss allowed by the offensive line.
Cleaning up these “little things” will be crucial, as will the development of young talent under pressure. With Manning’s potential, a stout defense, and Sarkisian’s proven leadership, the Longhorns have the pieces to go all the way. Expect Texas to compete for the SEC title and make a deep CFP run, potentially bringing a championship back to Austin for the first time since 2005.
Texas is poised for a 10-2 or 11-1 season, likely dropping one of the Ohio State or Georgia games but dominating their remaining slate. With a favorable SEC draw and elite talent, the Longhorns are set to return to the CFP, with a strong chance to compete for the national championship.
