What Will Atlanta Braves Do With Jurickson Profar?

Profar: Stay Or Go?

By: Colin Lacy

TheSouthernSportsEdition.com news services

There are so many questions swirling around the Major League Baseball world.

Whether there will be baseball in 2027? What the Collective Bargaining Agreement looks like? Will there be a lockout?

Another question on the mind of folks around the Atlanta Braves organization is whenever the Braves step on the field next, will Jurickson Profar be part of that plan?

Profar finished serving his second suspension due to performance-enhancing substances in the span of 2 years. Profar has only played in 80 games since he signed a three-year, $42 million deal prior to the 2025 season.

The switch-hitting bat was suspended for 80 games when he tested positive for a banned substance in 2025. Profar was popped for PEDs for a second time prior to the 2026 season and was issued a 162-game suspension by Major League Baseball.

While it was announced last week that it appears Profar is preparing to make his come back in 2027 (if there is baseball) when it was announced that Profar made his debut for the Venezuela Winter League’s Tiburones de La Guaira club.

Braves President of Baseball Operations Alex Anthopoulos said, “We realize it’s something we’re going to have to address, but we’d like to get through the winter and have a better handle on what the roster looks like and what’s going to happen between now and Spring Training with signings, role determinations, and all that stuff.”

While that doesn’t instill a ton of confidence that Profar will be back with Atlanta, I think that’s where most of the Braves organization is on the Profar situation.

After the second suspension, it was well known that Profar cleaned out his locker and left the team without any conversations. Ronald Acuna Jr. is on record saying that Profar was “unreachable” from anyone on the team.

While in the first two years of the three-year contract, the Braves have only had to pay Profar $6 million since the suspensions were un-paid, if he does return to the Braves in 2027, the organization will owe him the $15 million guaranteed on his contract for the final year.

There is so much to weigh in the decision of what the future of the Profar/Braves relationship looks like, but the most important that is going to be taken is the impact in the clubhouse if he returns.

Baseball clubhouses are a hallowed place for players and can be finicky at times. There are not many times that players express frustrations within the clubhouse like multiple Braves players have with the most recent Profar suspension, which tells you that it was pretty impactful blow to the confidence that the clubhouse has in Profar.

At this point, the off the field impact may be enough to cut ties with him after Profar has now let the clubhouse down twice in as many years.

Taking the emotions out of the equation, there also must be questions of what Profar is going to be on the field for the club. Again, Profar has only had 80 Major League games over the past 2 years and just 318 Abs in 2 years with none of either coming since September 28th of 2025.

In the limited 2025 season, Profar only produced a .245 average with 43 RBI.

It would take an unfathomable comeback for Profar’s return to be worth the hassle on the field for the Braves in my opinion, not to mention the immense amount of work it would take for him to be trusted in the clubhouse again.

Factor it all up, and I don’t know that the juice (pun intended) is worth the squeeze to have Profar continue in Atlanta.