PSR Tweaks
Tweaks For PSR?
By: Ron Reagin
TheSouthernSportsEdition.com news services
Friday’s first round of the Class 7A playoffs had a lot of lopsided games.
Eleven of the 16 games were decided by 21 points or more. Five were decided by 35 or more, and No. 4 Brookwood and No. 12 Grayson both won 49-0. No. 1 Valdosta’s 63-7 win over No. 32 West Forsyth was the biggest margin of the night.
The average margin was 26.9 points. That’s up from 23.4 in last year’s first round in the top classification and 21.3 in 2024.
So, were this year’s blowouts worse? A little. But they aren’t new. Friday had 11 of 16 games decided by 21 or more. Last year it was 10 of 16, and in 2024 it was 8 of 16.
Under the old format, region champions hosted another region’s No. 4 seed, and last year 7 of those 8 games were decided by 21 or more.
This year, PSR seeded the bracket 1 through 32, and the top 8 seeds hosted seeds 25 through 32.
Again, 7 of those 8 games were decided by 21 or more. Region 1 went 3-0 in that group, with No. 5 Lowndes beating No. 28 South Forsyth 62-27 and No. 7 Colquitt County beating No. 26 Lambert 52-26.
The only exception was the biggest upset of the night. No. 25 Archer went on the road to No. 8 North Cobb and won 24-17. A team seeded in the bottom 8 beat a top-8 seed in its own stadium, and Archer was the only one of the bottom 8 to win.
Now look at the middle of the seeding, the 8 games where seeds 9 through 16 hosted seeds 17 through 24. Only 4 of those 8 games were decided by 21 or more, and 3 were one-score games.
No. 15 Peachtree Ridge held off No. 18 Hillgrove 31-27, No. 14 Parkview outlasted No. 19 South Gwinnett 63-56, and No. 20 Richmond Hill went to No. 13 North Paulding and won 21-16. No. 17 East Coweta also won at No. 16 Denmark, 44-13.
Some have said PSR seeding would mean a lack of “early round upsets.” It didn’t Friday. Three teams won on the road as the lower seed, Archer, Richmond Hill and East Coweta, and the close games came between teams seeded close together.
The way I see it, PSR did what we’ve always said it would. It got the right 32 teams in, and after the top 10 or 12, the seeding was better. What it didn’t fix is the first-round blowouts, but it wasn’t built to.
This isn’t a new conversation. In 2021, then-GHSA executive director Robin Hines told GPB the “noncompetitive first rounds” hadn’t been “a financial boom for everybody.”
Right after making that point, he said he had asked whether a change “would be considered” moving forward, and “the answer was no.” Hines retired in 2024, and under his successor, Tim Scott, the GHSA executive committee approved PSR 66-1.
“Our goal is to make sure we’ve got the elite eight in the Elite 8 and the best four in the Final Four and the best two in the state championship,” Scott said.
So, what could change? One idea is byes for the top seeds. If the top 8 sat out the first week, the opening round would look like Friday’s games between seeds 9 through 24, which were the most competitive of the night.
The catch is that a clean bracket would mean a 24-team field, so 8 teams that made it this year would stay home. A playoff trip, even at 4-6, means something to those kids and communities.
The other is two divisions, with seeds 1 through 16 in one bracket and 17 through 32 in another, like Class A did when it split into two divisions. That would make the first round closer, but it would also mean two state champions in the same classification.
Some folks think that waters down the title, and it goes against the GHSA’s own stated goal of having the best teams meet in the later rounds.
Neither fix is perfect, and both have trade-offs. But Friday showed where the blowouts come from, and it’s not the seeding. It’s the nature of a 32-team bracket.









