JJ Lanier
Super Bowl Backups?
By: JJ Lanier
TheSouthernSportsEdition.com news services
One of the main topics of discussion as we exit the football season is the importance of having a capable backup at the quarterback position.
Teams like Green Bay and Miami struggled mightily when they were forced to rely on their 2nd string QB.
I mean, Miami had so much faith in Matt Moore they signed Jeff George’s twin brother from a different mother, Jay Cutler, and started him Week 1.
Teams like Minnesota, and obviously Philadelphia, we’re able to keep their season afloat despite losing their starting quarterbacks.
So, this got me thinking: How much faith should fans of the NFC South have in their respective team’s backup quarterback?
Since things could, and probably will change over the next few months, I’m going with who the backup quarterback was at the end of the season.
Atlanta Falcons: Matt Schaub. All you need to know is that Schaub is currently 54 going on 83 and over the past 2 years has only thrown three more passes in an actual NFL game than I have.
Look, I like Schaub’s game, from 7-8 years ago and if this were being written during his first stint with Atlanta I would be really high on his ability to lead the Falcons for an extended period, if needed.
Unfortunately, that’s not the case. I can’t imagine a scenario where Dan Quinn doesn’t bring someone else in back up Matt Ryan. Falcons’ fans better hope Ryan is the Cal Ripken of NFL Quarterbacks.
Carolina Panthers: Derek Anderson. See Matt Schaub. The only difference is I can count on Anderson to throw at least one red zone interception for every game he plays.
If Schaub actually played I feel like he would just hand the ball off every play, which is what I would want the Panthers to do with Anderson.
New Orleans Saints: Chase Daniel. This one is interesting, mainly because I have no idea how good Daniel is.
I know a lot of teams think highly of him and he’s made really good money over his 10 year career based on those opinions. I also know he’s never thrown more than 38 passes in a season.
In fact, he’s only thrown 78 passes in his entire career. Seriously, there’s not enough info on him for me to even poke fun at. He’s truly “a riddle wrapped in a mystery inside an enigma.”
Tampa Bay Buccaneers: Ryan Fitzpatrick. I guess out of all the backup quarterbacks the NFC South has to offer, Fitzpatrick is the best.
I’m not really sure that’s saying a whole lot though. I will say this, he did do an admirable job filling for Jameis Winston at various times this past year. And he has proven himself to be a decent quarterback in recent years.
I guess it’s not completely out of the realm of possibility to see him have the type of season Case Keenum had if Fitzpatrick needed to run the show in Tampa. Not saying it’s likely to happen, just that it’s not impossible.
Basically, while the NFC South may have the strongest group of starting of quarterbacks in the league, they also have the male version of the “Golden Girls” as their backups.
And if I’m being completely honest, with the exception of Ryan Fitzpatrick, I’m pretty sure I’d rather have Bea Arthur as my backup as opposed to the other three. You can even include Fitzpatrick if you’re giving me Betty White.
What Super Bowl LII Means For NFL
By: JJ Lanier
TheSouthernSportsEdition.com news services
After what seemed like 2 decades of underwhelming Super Bowl games, 3 out of the last 4 years have been anything but boring. You had New England’s win over Seattle 4 years ago.
New England’s come from behind, overtime victory over Atlanta last year. And of course, Philadelphia winning this year’s Super Bowl for every football fan not from the Boston area. So, here are a few observations from this year’s game.
1- I now have a huge man crush on Philadelphia’s head coach, Doug Pederson. His play calling and willingness to have faith in his offense to convert on some of those fourth downs is something that as a Carolina Panthers fan, feels foreign to me.
I just automatically assumed you were required to punt on 4th down, no matter the situation. Plus, Pederson makes me feel like my approach to Madden 2018- never punting, ever- means I too could be a NFL head coach.
Also, what he and Offensive Coordinator, Frank Reich, did in adjusting their offensive scheme to mesh with Nick Foles’ strength and comfort level, may be one of the more impressive coaching jobs I’ve seen in years.
2- Now that Nick Foles is a Super Bowl MVP- just marinate on that for a minute- what team in desperate need of a quarterback mortgages their future to tries and trade for him?
Also, will we see a run on teams overpaying for backup quarterbacks, they previously wouldn’t have thought twice about? If you thought the backup quarterback was the popular player among fans before this Super Bowl, I have a feeling you haven’t seen anything yet.
3- There are a plethora of reasons to be giddy watching Tom Brady and the Patriots lose, much like Nick Cage seems to take pride in making “Ghost Rider” movies, or really any movie where there’s no plot and a lot of things blow up, for that matter.
Regardless of how deep seeded that dislike is for both Patriots and/or their quarterback, you should be impressed with Brady.
I’m 37 years old and anytime I run a 5k in under 30 minutes I feel like the local news channel should be producing a segment on just how awesome and in shape I am.
Tom Brady is 3 years older than I am, and he just threw for over 500 yards in the Super Bowl!
I still felt like New England was somehow going to pull out a win when they were inside their own 10, with 58 seconds left because Tom Brady was the quarterback.
4- While New England’s run of 8 Super Bowl appearances in 17 years is incredible, what may be even more impressive is that every single one of them has been a good game. Upset win against the Rams in ‘01; game winning field goals against Panthers and Eagles in ‘03, ‘04; goal line interception in ‘15 against Seattle; last year’s overtime win versus Atlanta.
Throw in their two close losses to the Giants and this year’s game, and basically every Super Bowl New England has participated in has come down the wire. Look, I despise the Patriots as much as anyone whose last name isn’t Damon or Affleck, but they do put on a good show.
So, if you want the early odds on who will be back in the Super Bowl next year, my guess is New England and whatever NFC team has the best backup quarterback. I mean, the NFL is a copycat league, right?
Super Bowl Preview
By: JJ Lanier
TheSouthernSportsEdition.com news services
There’s a line in “Spaceballs” where Rick Moranis’ character, Dark Helmet, says “So, Lone Star, now you see that evil will always triumph because good is dumb.”
As soon as New England defeated Jacksonville, cementing a spot in their 8th Super Bowl over the past 16 years, that was the first thing that popped into my head.
Of course, after Philadelphia completely manhandled Minnesota, I suddenly had that part of movie playing in my head on a loop. (Good lord, I hope the commercials will be enjoyable).
That being said, allow me to be one of approximately 7,385 articles you’ll read on Super Bowl LII.
There will be fair number of juicy stories, mainly coming from the Patriots side. (Did Tom Brady finally win Patriot of the Week?!?!?)
You’ll get your share of “experts” over analyzing every last detail, down to the Eagles conversion rate on 3rd and 3, during their 1st possession of the 2nd quarter.
To me, it’s all going to come down to how Philadelphia performs. I know that sounds kind of basic, but let me explain.
You pretty much know what you’re going to get from New England, for the most part. Their defense will give up a fair amount of yardage, but will tighten up in the red zone. Besides the two drives Jacksonville had at the beginning of the game, they were only able to score 2 fields goals.
Offensively, Tom Brady will do what Tom Brady does in the Super Bowl, basically he’ll throw for 300 yards and 3 touchdowns.
You can almost count on all those things taking place.
So, the question is what will we get from Philadelphia? In regards to this, there are two specific things I’m curious to see.
The first, revolves around Philly’s defense. The Eagles are known for being opportunistic on the defensive side and that hasn’t changed over the past few years.
As great as Tom Brady is, and has been in Super Bowl games, he does take chances that Philadelphia should be able to take advantage of. As someone who had their defense in his fantasy league, when they get an interception they are looking to score. More often than most, they find the end zone.
Don’t get me wrong, Brady will take advantage of their aggressiveness; can Philadelphia capitalize on Brady’s mistakes as well?
The next concerns both the Eagles head coach and offensive coordinator, Doug Pederson and Frank Reich, respectively.
You know the Patriots are going to come up with some sort of scheme to slow down Philadelphia’s running game, which has been one of the league’s best throughout the season.
Knowing that, can Pederson and Reich put together a game plan that will ease the comfort level of Nick Foles, so that he’ll be confident to make the throws you know he is going to have to make.
So far in playoffs, they have done a terrific job with this against two defenses in Atlanta and Minnesota, that should have been more dominant than they were.
Philadelphia has an awful lot of talent on that side of the ball and should be able to move the ball with more success than New England’s first two playoff opponents.
When all is said and done, who will walk away victorious? Well, I’ve learned not to bet against New England, so I guess I’ll go with the Patriots.
Then again, I may not even watch the game- it’s been a while since I sat down and watched “Spaceballs”.
Jaguars Roar
By: JJ Lanier
TheSouthernSportsEdition.com news services
When you look back over the NFL season, it shouldn’t really be all that surprising that the Jacksonville Jaguars were at least able to make the playoffs.
For one, it’s become a yearly ritual for the playoffs to consist of around a half dozen teams that didn’t make it to the postseason the year before. Jacksonville was a hot pick to be one of those teams last year, until Blake Bortles did his best Akili Smith impersonation and the Jaguars season prominently went the way of Kevin Spacey’s career.
Coming into this season, Jacksonville had a favorable schedule, a defense that people thought would be very good (not sure anyone thought they would be this good) and a possible running attack led by Leonard Fournette. As long as Bortles could semi keep it together they would have a legit shot of returning to the playoffs.
However, all that being said, you’re straight up lying if you predicted Jacksonville to be playing in the AFC Championship game.
Yes, I know they had Buffalo at home, another “surprise” team that was more or less a mirror image of how Jacksonville plays.
And sure, they did best Pittsburgh, in Pittsburgh, back in Week Five. But c’mon, if I told you Roethlisberger was going to throw for over 400 yards and the Steelers would put up 42 points, how much a chance would you give Jacksonville to win?
Probably about as much a chance as most will give them in Foxboro Stadium. Well, as a former president once said “Fool me once, shame on – shame on you. Fool me – you can’t get fooled again.” Obviously, that isn’t quite how the saying goes, but you get the gist.
I don’t expect the Jaguars defense to be able to stop Brady completely, but they are stingy enough to slow down the Patriots offense and should be able to keep Jacksonville in the game; barring their offense decides to help them out.
This of course, is the big question. You have to imagine Belichick will load the box in order to stop one of the league’s best rushing attacks, but that’s easier said than done.
The Patriots defense is much improved from where they were at the beginning of the season, but Jacksonville should be able to have success on the ground.
However, like every other conversation concerning the Jaguars over the past two years, it will come down to Blake Bortles and whether or not he can- 1. Make the important throw when needed, or 2. Not turn into Ryan Leaf. At this point, I’d feel more comfortable trying to predict which athlete/music mogul Khloe Kardashian is going to date next. (Officially, my vote is for Kyrie Irving. It just feels right, you know?)
One thing that New England has been able to use as an advantage in home playoff games of years past, but that may not be much of a factor against Jacksonville, is the weather.
As of right now, the skies will be clear and the temperature will be in the 50’s. Granted it’s not Jacksonville, FL weather, but it’s hardly the type of weather that should hinder their play.
I know New England is a heavy favorite, as they should be, but I just can’t shake this feeling Jacksonville will put up more of a fight than most expect.
Regardless, making it to the AFC Championship is farther than just about anyone would’ve imagined before the season started….no matter what they tell you.
Mark Fox Is SEC Basketball
By: JJ Lanier
TheSouthernSportsEdition.com news services
If any SEC program had a winning basketball team, excluding Kentucky and Florida, would their fan base even care?
Actually, if they were winning the fan base would probably get behind them. I guess the better question is: If any SEC basketball program were a smidge better than mediocre, would anyone truly pay attention?
I ask this because for the most part SEC fans will alter their weekend schedule depending on what time their football team plays, but will really only watch basketball if the alternative is “Once Upon A Time” and even then it may come down to whether or not the latter is a rerun.
It’s kind of shame to be honest, because over the last few seasons the level of talent and competition within the conference has continued to grow.
One of the reasons for this semi-resurgence has been coaching. While football has taken a hit over the last couple seasons, relative to where it was because of missing out on some coaching hires at high profile programs, basketball has seemingly done a much better job with who they have brought in.
Take Tennessee for example and their hiring of Rick Barnes; who after prior stops at Clemson and Texas must have a wardrobe made up completely of different shades of orange.
Even though it feels as if Barnes bases his diagramming of plays and clock management off of NBA 2K18, he does a good job of recruiting and at least gets his teams into the tournament.
Avery Johnson is looking to be the correct hire at Alabama and even though Florida is off to a less than desired start, I don’t think anyone is questioning their choice of Mike White.
Throw in proven coaches like Ben Homeland, Bruce Pearl, and Frank Martin (coming off an unexpected Final Four 4 last year) and you can see why teams have started to close the gap with Kentucky, which a few years ago seemed insurmountable.
That being said, no one coach personifies SEC Basketball more than Georgia head coach, Mark Fox.
Fox is currently in his 9th season as the Bulldogs coach, and entered this season with an overall record of 145-118 (.551), 70-68 (.507) in conference play and zero tournament wins in their only two appearances in eight years. Yet, there doesn’t seem to be much rumbling about his job security, at least not with any regularity.
Personally, I think this is for 3 reasons:
- Fox is the anti Jim Harrick. Basically, he’s a genuinely good guy that runs a clean program, and won’t embarrass the entire athletic department and university.
- Even though Fox hasn’t had all that much success in Athens, he hasn’t been an object failure, either. If Georgia were to let him go, would they really be able to bring in someone better? He’s more less become the Ryan Tannehill of college basketball coaches.
- He wasn’t that big of a name when Georgia initially hired him, so what Fox has been able to accomplish is fairly realistic to the expectations coming in. Bigger name, bigger expectations.
My point is, when you’re sitting on your couch, or laying bed, trying to decide if you should watch yet another episode of “Duck Dynasty” or something a little different, give SEC Basketball a try.
They’re still a work in progress, but it will be well worth your time. I mean, at the very least you’re guaranteed to see Barnes make a fool of himself, which is well worth the price of admission.
Familiar Swamp For Mullen
By: JJ Lanier
TheSouthernSportsEdition.com news services
With everything that has transpired in Knoxville over the past few weeks, I imagine the inner sanctum of the Athletic Department is reminiscent of something you would see on The Real Housewives of Atlanta.
While Tennessee’s search for a football head coach has made the Cleveland Browns seem like a stable organization, all the attention being paid the Volunteers has overshadowed the possible game changing hire happening in Gainesville, Fla.
I wrote a few weeks ago that Georgia is set up nicely to dominate the SEC East for the next 2-3 years, possibly even longer, depending on who the Gators brought in the lead their football team.
I know there was a lot of chatter about Florida hiring Chip Kelly or Scott Frost, but bringing in either of those two would’ve been a much more riskier move than bringing back former Offensive Coordinator, Dan Mullen.
Don’t get me wrong, Kelly was fantastic at Oregon, but part of me wonders how well his philosophy would work in the SEC. And Frost has exceeded expectations at UCF, but he has no Power 5 experience.
The one thing Florida needs right now is some stability within their program, and they should get that and more with Mullen.
It’s easy to talk about it being a good hire because of Mullen’s familiarity with the Gator program, as well as his success with Mississippi State, which are both valid points and large reasons why he’s a great fit for the Florida program. I want to focus on the whole “stability” aspect of the hire, though.
It’s been well documented Florida’s struggles since Steve Spurrier left- and yes even though he was extremely successful during his tenure, I’m including Urban Meyer since he left after only six seasons.
Including interim coaches, Dan Mullen will be the 8th Florida Gator head football coach since Spurrier left the school in 2001. Just as a frame of reference, Vanderbilt has only had four different coaches during that same period.
As important as is it to get the Florida program back into the National Title conversation on a regular basis, it’s equally important for the program to have a coach that will be there for a while.
That’s not to say Mullen won’t ever leave, but he had plenty of opportunities to leave Starkville, which one can assume is what most people not from Starkville would be more than eager to do. Yet, it took the Florida head coaching job to pry him away.
Besides getting a coach that knows the program, has experience within the SEC, is aware of the fansbase and their expectations and just a good coach; Florida has someone that probably won’t be looking to leave anytime soon.
Mullen may not have been the flashy hire, like Kelly and Frost would’ve been, but he was the right hire.
Look, I’m not saying the Florida will be vying for the SEC East title along with Georgia next year, but there is enough young talent there it shouldn’t surprise anyone if Mullen has them back in contention within the next year or two.
Then again, I’m also the guy who applauded Florida profusely on the McElwain hire, so what the hell do I know.
Hopefully, I’m at least right on this hire. If not, I guess I can always go back to watching The Real Housewives. Or the Tennessee Athletic Department? I can never tell those two apart.
The Perfect Playoff System
By: JJ Lanier
TheSouthernSportsEdition.com news services
Let me start by saying that I have absolutely no issue with Alabama receiving the fourth and final spot in the College Football Playoffs.
It’s not so much because I think the Tide deserve to be in the playoffs, but rather because of this lesson I learned at the age of 14; if you don’t want to be left out of something then don’t give them a reason to leave you out.
In this instance, both Alabama and Ohio State gave the committee reasons not to be chosen as that fourth team. Because of that I would’ve been fine with either of those teams making in.
The issue I have isn’t with who made the playoffs, it’s with the system itself. And no, I’m not listening to the Danny Kanell “Everybody is sucking at the SEC teet” greatest hits that he brings out this time of year.
Most everyone was pleased to get rid of the BCS because it didn’t allow for any subjectivity, so now we have a process that is almost completely subjective.
The guidelines with which the committee follows are reminiscent of a Jackson Pollack painting, they just throw whatever criteria they decide to use that particular season and voilà, by the end of the year they have four teams and a playoff.
One of the things I hate the most is that only the Power 5 conferences truly have a shot at making the playoffs. I have no idea how Central Florida would contend with Clemson in a opening round game, but I’m sure nobody gave the Coastal Carolina baseball team a second thought last year, until they won the College World Series.
And please don’t tell me teams like UCF need to schedule better out of conference games either. Did you not hear the all knowing and powerful Nick Saban talk about P5 schools only playing other P5 schools? No legit playoff contender wants to schedule someone like the Knights; if you win you were supposed to; if you lose it could all but end your playoff hopes.
There’s just something wrong with a competition that basically excludes half of participants before it even begins.
They also need to figure out something with conference championships, too. As I mentioned, under the current rules I have no issue with Alabama being in the playoffs.
However, those rules are stupid if a team that didn’t even participate in their conference title game, makes it the final four.
Notice I’m not talking about a team that loses in their conference title game, but rather a team that doesn’t even get there. The fact it’s happened two years in a row makes me trust this process about as much as I’d trust a male politician at a high school prom.
The solution is simple, if you don’t make it to the conference title game you don’t make it to the college football playoffs. I know that can be harsh when you’re looking at a team like Alabama this year, who’s only lost happens to be within the conference, but timing is everything.
You think Georgia’s in the playoffs if they win that first meeting with Auburn, but lose by 23 in the rematch? Possibly, but I doubt it.
Of course, I’ll end up watching all three of the games, which is exactly what the NCAA is counting on. So, they win yet again and it’s likely nothing will change.
Sorry UCF, I really did try my best.
The Super NFC South
By: JJ Lanier
TheSouthernSportsEdition.com news services
At the beginning of the season it looked as though a battle would be taking place between the AFC West and the NFC South for NFL dominance.
As we approach the final stretch of the season it looks like the AFC West will only get one team into the playoffs and that basically because they have to have at least one representative.
On the other hand, the NFC South has held up their end of the preseason bargain and are looking to be the toughest division in football.
The question regarding the division isn’t whether or not they’ll get two teams into the playoffs, but could they possibly get three?
For the sake of argument let’s go ahead and assume that Philadelphia (East), Minnesota (North), Saints (South) and the Los Angeles Rams (West) will all win their respective divisions.
Obviously, anything can happen over the next few weeks, but my brain is fried on college football playoff hypotheticals, so I’m taking the easy way out on this one.
Were this scenario to play out, that would really leave only four viable teams for the remaining wild card spots: Seahawks, Lions, Falcons, and Panthers.
Seattle has probably the second easiest schedule of those four teams, but I just don’t have the confidence in the Mom to make a legitimate run at the playoffs.
Their offense has resorted to Russell Wilson running around in the backfield and making some sort of ridiculous throw to Doug Baldwin, off of a busted play.
With injuries plaguing the defensive side of the ball the “Legion Of Boom” has turned into the Legion of “We’d like to hit you hard, but we’re a little fragile right now, so we’re just going to push you and hope that you fall down.”
Could Seattle make the playoffs? Absolutely. Will they ultimately make me regret saying that they won’t make it? Without a doubt.
So, that leaves Detroit as the main threat to the NFC South sending 3 teams to the playoffs.
There are two things the Lions have going for them. First, they have a much easier schedule from here on out. of their remaining games, Detroit doesn’t play a single team with a winning record.
It’s almost the exact opposite for Atlanta and Carolina. Secondly, and this could be what propels Detroit into the playoffs, is that Carolina still has one more game against Atlanta and New Orleans, while the Falcons and Saints will play each other twice. Did I mention they both have a game with Minnesota still on their schedules, too?
The one thing that both the Falcons and Panthers do have on the Lions though, is that they are currently one and two games ahead of Detroit in the standings, respectively.
Not to mention, both teams hold the tiebreaker due to victories earlier in the season. So really, Atlanta has a two game lead and the Panthers’ lead is three. That’s difficult to overcome when you only have a handful of games left to make it happen.
The entire division has their work cut out for them is they hope to get three teams into the playoffs.
Detroit is in prime position to run the table while the entire NFC South will be dueling it out amongst themselves- reminiscent of what the SEC West used to be years ago.
Regardless, ¾ of the NFC South has lived up to the hype, which is pretty damn impressive, when you think about it.
Georgia To Dominate SEC East For Years To Come
By: JJ Lanier
TheSouthernSportsEdition.com news services
Timing is everything.
I met my wife at an impromptu party my roommates and I had in Chapel Hill over 17 years ago. We were originally supposed to hang out with another group of friends, but just didn’t want to, so we decided to have people over to our apartment, instead.
Had that not taken place I never would have met my wife and would be 37 years old, probably living in my parents’ basement, still believing BASEketball is the perfect date movie.
The reason I mention this- besides never passing up an opportunity for a BASEketball reference- is the timing is set up perfectly for Georgia to dominate the SEC East over the next few football seasons.
Part of the reason is Georgia has set themselves up nicely for the future. They’ve got a good coach in Kirby Smart and strong recruiting classes coming in.
The other reason, and this is where the whole “timing” things comes in, is the level of competition they’ll be facing within their own division.
If people have referred to the SEC East these past 3-4 seasons as being a dumpster fire, the next 2-3 years will be a flaming inferno of mediocrity. You might as well start putting together those Poseidon gifs right now; you’ll be able to use them.
I like some of the progress being made at schools like Vanderbilt, Missouri, South Carolina, and Kentucky. But, with all due respect to those four programs, unless something drastic we’re to change over the next year or two, neither of those schools should be able to compete with Georgia on the field.
And let’s be honest, Georgia’s path to the SEC East dominance won’t be because they’re able to consistently beat those four teams I just mentioned. Their success will be based on the outcome of their matchups against Florida and Tennessee.
They say if a quarterback drafted in the first round becomes a bust it can set a franchise back three or four years. I believe Florida and Tennessee are about to find out the same thing can be said for coaches too.
(You could argue, and correctly I might add, that after coaches like Ron Zook and Derek Dooley, both programs are well aware that fact.)
Let’s start with Tennessee. I know just about every Vols fan is salivating at the possibility of Jon Gruden returning to Knoxville. I guess it could happen, but so could me winning a Pulitzer for my article on Lane Kiffin’s tweets.
Just because it can happen, doesn’t mean it will, or even that it should. Whoever takes over in Tennessee, success won’t happen overnight.
Florida is basically in the same boat as Tennessee, they’re just not taking on quite as much water as he Volunteers.
There is some talent in Gainesville, and with the right coach- all indications point to Chip Kelly, as of now- it may only take a year or two before they are back where they believe they belong.
Since Spurrier left in 2001, they’ve pretty much struck out with everyone they’ve brought in, with the exception of Urban Meyer. Granted, Meyer’s hiring almost outweighs the other three coaching disasters, but not completely. I just can’t shake the feeling that Florida will somehow screw this up.
Either way, the bottom line is this: the next 2-3 years are set up perfectly for Georgia to dominate the SEC East. Coaching and talent will play a huge role, but like with most things in life, timing is everything.
Who’s In….Over Georgia?
By: JJ Lanier
TheSouthernSportsEdition.com news services
At this point in the season it is almost a foregone conclusion that Alabama and Georgia will meet up not only for the SEC Championship title game, but will enter that game as the first and second ranked teams in college football.
If that scenario were to play out obviously the winner would make it to the playoffs. The more interesting topic to me is would a 1-loss SEC runner-up make it too?
There are probably about 20 different hypothetical outcomes, but for this purpose I’ll go ahead and put Oklahoma in the playoffs (wins out including Big XII championship) and Alabama. (No disrespect to Georgia who could easily win the SEC, but it’s easier to go over scenarios for one SEC team as opposed to two, and as of today I personally think Alabama is the better team).
So, with two teams already in the playoff picture, who are some of the other teams Georgia would be contending with.
Wisconsin– It would be hard on paper to leave out an undefeated Big Ten champion, if that’s what ends up happening. However, I don’t think the Badgers are very good and their best win will be against,ultimately, a 3 loss Ohio State team.
Regardless of what the committee does, you can’t convince me they are better than Georgia.
Clemson– If the Tigers were to win out and take the ACC crown, they’re in no matter what. Defending champs, conference champs, impressive resumé, only 1 loss; there’s no way the committee will keep them out.
Another loss though, and I don’t see how they make it.
Miami- I haven’t thought all that much of the Hurricanes throughout the season, but if they were to win out that would include victories over Virginia Tech, Notre Dame, and Clemson.
Hard to put Georgia in over Miami if that were take place. (On a side note, if Miami made it in over Georgia what’s the over/under on the amount time elapsed before a video of Mark Richt urinating in a stuffed Uga goes viral?)
Notre Dame- The Fighting Irish are really the wild card here.
If they were to win out, it would include a victory over Miami, essentially knocking out the Hurricanes.
It would also leave them tied with Georgia, leading to the question, “What do you value more, head to head or overall strength of schedule?”
If you’re a Bulldog fan, you’re going to say head to head, as you should. If you’re a Notre Dame fan, it’s overall strength of schedule. And while it’s not completely an apples to apples comparison, it is worth mentioning that last year, when it came down to OSU and PSU, the commute went in favor of Ohio State’s overall schedule instead of Penn State’s victory over the Buckeyes.
As I mentioned above there are plenty of other scenarios that could play out over the next few makes, making what I just wrote entirely obsolete.
Regardless, here’s the point I’m trying to make: In the last few years, you could argue that a one loss, SEC runner up was deserving of making the playoffs because of the conference’s overall strength.
Ironically, the one year it may come to fruition, the one year where the two best teams in college football could possibly reside within the SEC, is the one year that the conference’s lack of overall strength may be what keeps it from happening.
